Error Rates in Measuring Teacher and School Performance Based on Student Test Score Gains

I was recently pointed to the 2010 USDOE/Mathematica paper that shares this post’s name. One has to think that Rockoff and Kane et al. have seen it, but nobody seems to ever mention it. From the abstract:

Simulation results suggest that value-added estimates are likely to be noisy using the amount of data that are typically used in practice. Type I and II error rates for comparing a teacher’s performance to the average are likely to be about 25 percent with three years of data and 35 percent with one year of data.

Those numbers are awful. What’s interesting to me is that they aren’t even that much better when using three years of data, as compared to one year. I had thought they would probably improve a lot with triple the data. They just stay bad.

This study used a fairly simple VAM, similar to what they do in Tennessee, so that’s one possible critique. But the fact is, this is the only research I’ve seen that seriously attempts to address the trustworthiness of VAM at the teacher and school level. Everybody else seems to be ignoring it, as if there’s no cost to making arbitrarily incorrect judgements about teachers’ work. This paper is worth a look.

One thought on “Error Rates in Measuring Teacher and School Performance Based on Student Test Score Gains

  1. I wonder how the error would fare in the context of MOOCs? Or even lecture-scale courses?
    Has there been any value-added studies in higher Ed where these scales are common?
    There is an absence of state exams (though there are some common exams) so while the N per teacher is very large, the population across teachers is small (the exact opposite of k-12).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s